Tool Steel for Press Tools: D2 (HCHCr) vs OHNS vs Carbide
The steel used for punches, die inserts and cutting elements decides how long a press tool runs between regrinds, and how many parts it can make before the cutting elements are replaced. It is one of the biggest reasons two quotations for the "same" tool can differ. Here are the three options you will most often see on Indian tool quotations.
OHNS (Oil Hardening Non-Shrinking steel)
OHNS (similar to AISI O1) is an oil-hardening tool steel that is easy to machine and heat treat.
- Good for: low-volume tools, simple blanking and forming tools, prototypes, non-critical parts
- Strengths: lower cost, easy to work, good dimensional stability after hardening
- Limitations: lower wear resistance than D2, so cutting edges dull sooner on long runs
D2 / HCHCr (High Carbon High Chromium)
D2, often called HCHCr in India, has roughly 1.5% carbon and 12% chromium. It is the workhorse for punches and die inserts in progressive tools.
- Good for: medium to high-volume progressive and compound dies, most steel, brass and copper parts
- Strengths: high wear resistance, holds a sharp edge, typically hardened to around 58–62 HRC
- Limitations: more brittle than lower-alloy steels, so it needs correct heat treatment and well-designed punch geometry
For most production progressive dies, D2 is the usual choice for cutting elements.
HCHCR full form, hardness and equivalents
- Full form: High Carbon High Chromium steel
- Common grades: AISI D2 (DIN 1.2379, JIS SKD11) and D3 (DIN 1.2080)
- Typical working hardness: about 58–62 HRC after hardening and tempering
- Why toolmakers use it: high wear resistance for long-running punches and die inserts
OHNS full form, hardness and equivalents
- Full form: Oil Hardening Non-Shrinking steel
- Common grade: AISI O1 (DIN 1.2510)
- Typical working hardness: about 57–61 HRC
- Why toolmakers use it: easy to machine and harden with little distortion, good for low-volume tools and gauges
Hardness values are typical; the exact figure depends on heat treatment and the toolmaker's choice for each component.
Tungsten carbide
Carbide inserts and punches are far harder and more wear-resistant than any tool steel.
- Good for: very long runs (millions of strokes), abrasive materials, thin electrical laminations and terminals where edges must stay sharp
- Strengths: dramatically longer intervals between regrinds
- Limitations: expensive, brittle under shock or misalignment, and needs specialised grinding
Carbide only pays off when the volume is high and the tool, press and feeding are well controlled. In the wrong application it chips.
Other components
Not every part of a tool needs premium steel:
- Die sets and plates: usually mild steel or medium-carbon steel
- Pilots and guides: hardened tool steel, since accuracy depends on them
- High-speed steel (HSS) punches: sometimes used for small piercing punches that need extra toughness
Quick comparison table
| Property | OHNS (O1) | HCHCR (D2) | Tungsten carbide |
|---|---|---|---|
| Wear resistance | Moderate | High | Very high |
| Toughness | Good | Moderate | Low (brittle) |
| Typical hardness | ~57–61 HRC | ~58–62 HRC | Far harder than tool steel |
| Relative cost | Low | Medium | High |
| Best for | Low volume, prototypes | Most production dies | Very long runs |
How to choose
| Situation | Usual choice for cutting elements |
|---|---|
| Prototype or a few thousand parts | OHNS |
| Typical production progressive die | D2 / HCHCr |
| Millions of parts, thin or abrasive material | Carbide inserts in critical stations |
Ask your toolmaker to state the steel and hardness for cutting elements in the quotation. It is one of the 10 questions to ask a progressive tool manufacturer, and it explains a lot of the price difference covered in what decides progressive die cost.
Sizing the press as well? Try the free press tonnage calculator.
Not sure what your part needs? Send us the drawing and annual volume and we will recommend the tooling material along with the progressive tool design.
